--- Summary
I would like to leave a review without stars (neutral) but that's not possible, so I give it 3 which is exactly in the middle. For me, the stars are 0, but that's my personal opinion.

If I had to review the perfume itself, I would say that the black bottle MAYBE is the only one that is somewhat tolerable.

--- Scent
...it's a spray that smells like aerosol with a strong synthetic fragrance. Like the ones we spray in the room to kill flies, sorry but that's what all these deodorants remind me of. If you've tried 'deodorant' sprays like Fa, Str8, Axe, etc... it smells EXACTLY like that, for me there's no difference at all.

It reminds me of high school days when we didn't know what to do and we would douse ourselves with deodorant/perfume/cologne spray thinking that the more something smells the better it is. Whenever someone passes by me and smells like that kind of aerosol deodorant/perfume, I really wonder. Also, when I put it on, it smelled so strong I almost fainted, after a while I think it stopped smelling at all. I mean, if I could say it smells strong at first and then just keeps a subtle scent, I'd say ok, but this one, as long as it smells, it could kill even cockroaches in the room and then after a while it just stops smelling.

The mistake is clearly mine for buying them, I use a deodorant that has antibacterial action, my favorite is perky and actually without its own scent or with a barely noticeable one because it doesn't need to cover anything with fragrance, it prevents the creation of bacteria and therefore bad odor. What exactly does this do, cover sweat odor with fragrance? When its scent fades, what happens, do we start to stink?

~~~
Personally, to smell nice I use a good cologne when it's for something formal but I always use body lotion which not only smells great, is never too strong, never stops smelling and when you pass by someone you leave a scent of freshness and it also helps the skin, with hydration and best of all, the longer you use it the more you smell like that because it's absorbed by the pores and if you sweat the lotion is activated and you smell great even when sweaty.

--- Conclusion
It's clearly a matter of preference, since they're cheap get the black one to try, if you like these kinds of scents then you'll like the black one.