I give 5 stars because at first glance they look very good. I will test them on some hikes in the next few weeks and will update. The reason I am rushing to write this review is to warn anyone who buys them before trying them on in person. Don't be misled by the size chart, get them in the size you usually wear in sports shoes. I initially bought size 41 (while I wear 42 in sports shoes) because that was preferable according to the size chart, but they were very tight in terms of the shoe's width (the length was not prohibitive) and I immediately exchanged them for size 42. As soon as I put on the 42 it was clear that it would have been a mistake to keep the 41. At first, they seem like a very good choice for their price.

edit: First hike at Artemisio with a lot of mud and different terrains along the route, the shoes were extremely comfortable throughout and made me feel confident. Nice grip and warm. Size 42 turned out to be ideal for me

Perfect as sports shoes! Very comfortable and warm! Absolutely satisfied and at a very good price for what they offer!

Very beautiful, very comfortable, very light!!! Comfortable fit on the foot, like walking on air..recommended to use spray for waterproofing