Regarding the size: I’m 1.84 m tall and weigh 107 kg. I got XL and it’s very comfortable, even a little large, but when I ride, the legs ride up quite high, up to my calves, because they’re wide. I’d like them to sit lower, since a little water sometimes gets in from the boot.
I won’t talk about waterproofing; everyone has already covered that. But I will say what really impressed me. On my big bike, I had an inexplicable fall before a traffic light in the rain at around 10 km/h, probably because of oil. I didn’t understand what happened—I hit the ground quite hard, with a little sliding and so on. I got up immediately, picked up the bike, and pulled over to see what damage the pants had suffered on their very first outing, since I was wearing a classic €5 tarp-like jacket on top. Miraculously, the pants were completely undamaged, even though from how the fall felt, I expected the entire right side to be destroyed. At home, after inspecting them carefully inside and out with a flashlight, I found two very small, pinhead-sized abrasions high up on the hip; barely any light showed through. I patched them with PVC glue.